At the Great Wall of China, a traveler spotted a folding fan at a vendor’s stand. It seemed like the perfect souvenir to bring home.
The vendor’s asking price was 125 yuan, about $18. After a few minutes of bargaining, the traveler bought the fan for 30 yuan, a little over $4. His tour group congratulated him on his negotiating skills. He had brought the price down substantially—and everyone thought he had gotten a great deal.
The next day, someone from the group saw the exact same fan in a Beijing store for 10 yuan, around $1.50.
Suddenly, that great deal looked very different.
The fan purchase illustrates the anchoring effect. That is, the tendency to rely too heavily on the first piece of information received when making a decision.
In this case, 125 yuan became the reference point. The group judged the final price against the vendor’s opening offer rather than what the fan sold for elsewhere. At 30 yuan, the fan seemed like a bargain—even though it cost three times as much as it did in the store.
The traveler had negotiated a substantial discount. What he hadn’t established was whether the starting price was reasonable.
That distinction matters. A lower price still may not be a fair price, and a large discount does not equal a good value.
Fortunately, this was a relatively inexpensive souvenir. However, in the workplace, a mistake like this can carry much higher stakes.
An initial price, proposal, or estimate can give a conversation a starting point. But it should not become the standard simply because someone mentioned it first.
When faced with an unrealistic offer, a negotiator can take a few practical steps:
Recognize the anchor. Consider whether the opening number reflects credible information or is simply setting expectations in the other party’s favor.
Address the gap. Clearly explain when an offer falls outside a reasonable range rather than treating it as an acceptable starting point.
Present a supported alternative. Make a counteroffer grounded in research, comparable prices, or clearly defined requirements.
Keep the discussion focused on value. It is not just how far the other party will move from the opening offer, but what makes the final agreement reasonable.
The goal is to avoid spending the entire conversation negotiating around a number that never deserved that much influence.
The most useful question from this story is not, “How much did the price come down?” But instead, “What makes this a good deal?”
Use that question in your workplace conversations about everything. It belongs in any decisions where an impressive discount can easily draw attention away from the price being paid. Is 20% off worth it, when they raised the price last month by 30%?
Before entering any negotiation, research alternatives, know what is a reasonable range, and decide what you are willing to accept. When an unexpected offer appears, pause and check the facts instead of immediately bargaining from it.
This experience brings about a simple reminder for you. When you want to negotiate, be prepared. Getting someone to move away from their opening price is only part of the job. Knowing what a fair resolution looks like is what makes the movement worth it.
If you need more help with your SALES SKILLS or other communication skills, check out one of our upcoming Improving Communication Public Classes.
JEP
Subscribe to the IC weekly newsletter for tips and advice on your communication skills!
Effective communication is empowering. Get started on your path to being more clear, brief, and effective.
Upcoming Classes